Two criteria determine if a segment needs dedicated page: traffic volume and message distance.
Traffic volume threshold: If a segment drives less than 500 visitors per month across all campaigns, it probably doesn't justify dedicated page. Share a page with similar segment. If it drives 1,000+ visitors monthly, dedicated page is worth the effort.
Message distance: If two segments have significantly different belief gaps, they need different pages. Compliance-driven doubts training effectiveness. Breach-reactive needs speed proof. Those are different enough to justify separate pages even if traffic is moderate.
Pull traffic estimates from your channel plan (playbook 2). Example:
Cybersecurity training monthly traffic:
- Compliance-driven: 1,800 visitors (LinkedIn 800 + Google search 600 + industry sites 400)
- Breach-reactive: 400 visitors (remarketing only)
- Proactive: 1,200 visitors (LinkedIn 700 + industry sites 500)
Decision matrix:
- Compliance-driven: HIGH volume (1,800), needs dedicated page
- Breach-reactive: LOW volume (400) but HIGH message distance (urgency focus vs compliance focus), dedicated page justified
- Proactive: HIGH volume (1,200), HIGH message distance (ROI focus), dedicated page justified
Result: 3 dedicated pages needed.
Lead gen tools monthly traffic:
- Paid-skeptic: 2,200 visitors (LinkedIn 900 + Google 800 + content 500)
- LinkedIn-first: 900 visitors (LinkedIn 600 + content 300)
- List-skeptic: 800 visitors (content 500 + remarketing 300)
- Tool-chooser: 1,100 visitors (Google 700 + remarketing 400)
Decision matrix:
- Paid-skeptic: HIGH volume (2,200), HIGH message distance (economic comparison focus), dedicated page
- LinkedIn-first: MEDIUM volume (900), HIGH message distance (channel comparison focus), dedicated page
- List-skeptic: MEDIUM volume (800), MEDIUM message distance (could potentially share with paid-skeptic as both are skeptics), test dedicated first
- Tool-chooser: HIGH volume (1,100), HIGH message distance (vendor comparison focus), dedicated page
Result: 4 dedicated pages (could test combining list-skeptic with paid-skeptic if resources limited).
Apply this framework to your segments. High volume alone doesn't justify page if message distance is low. High message distance alone doesn't justify page if volume is tiny (under 300 monthly). Both criteria together create clear need.